Pick hardness

topic posted Fri, October 27, 2006 - 5:44 PM by  Unsubscribed
I was looking at this interesting book on bluegrass playing in which the author suggests that you use an extra hard pick because the pick shouldn't bend; the wrist should (in a hammering motion, not a turning the doorknob motion).

What do you all use?
posted by:
Unsubscribed
  • Joe
    Joe
    offline 8

    Re: Pick hardness

    Sat, October 28, 2006 - 10:59 PM
    Hi Pasha,

    I'm using Dunlop Stubby 1.0's right now. I used to use a Dave Grisman signature that was quite rounded on the ends. It was marked with a particular thickness, but I do know it was one of the thickest, hardest picks I ever used. No flex whatsoever. I'm guessing it must have been about a 1.2 or so. I lost it at some point in the past and haven't found one quite like it since. A lot of the time, though I find myself now playing without a pick at all. I just keep my hand in the same position it would be in if I held the pick and use my index fingernail. I have hard nails, so it works out okay for me...
    • Re: Pick hardness

      Tue, October 31, 2006 - 6:43 AM
      Those Grisman picks are very thick, but have a very rounded "point" so that you get a reduced attack as opposed to traditional shaped points. I guess this is to get the jazzier sound, but sometimes you need that full attack, I think. For those situations, I use the same picks I use on guitar.....the black nylon Jim Dunlap 1.00 model.

      As for the wrist, as I guitar player I'm sure I use too much on mandolin regardless of which pick I'm using.....

Recent topics in "Tribe of the Wild Mandolin"

Topic Author Replies Last Post
Greek Bouzoukis?? Chris 11 November 27, 2007
Pinky out or in? Unsubscribed 5 October 21, 2007
New here - Advice sought - how do I start??? Ali 12 July 10, 2007
Interesting "discovery" to share. Brian 1 July 10, 2007